Clyson Windows & Doors (920) 242-2424

Repair or replace? How to decide on your windows

Some windows need a small fix. Others have reached the end. Here is how Tim decides, window by window.

Replace it when

  • Rot has spread through the sash joints and into the frame, not just the sill.
  • It is already a cheap replacement that has failed: fogged glass, broken balances, cracked vinyl.
  • You need something the old window can't do, such as egress from a bedroom.
  • It is drafty and hard to open, and you want windows that simply work.
  • Repairing it properly would cost more than a good new window.

See window replacement.

Repair it when

  • The window is original wood and the frame is solid when you press a screwdriver into the sill and lower corners.
  • The problems are mechanical: broken sash cords, painted shut, loose or rattling, missing putty, a cracked pane.
  • It has leaded, art or wavy glass, or an unusual shape.

These are quick, inexpensive fixes. See window repair.

What about energy savings?

New windows stop drafts, add insulated glass and are easier to open, lock and clean. If your existing windows are sound, weatherstripping and a storm window are a cheaper way to get part of that gain. Tim will price both so you can compare.

What about lead paint?

Assume any window painted before 1978 has lead paint. Intact paint is not the hazard; dust from friction and sanding is. Both repair and replacement disturb it, so either way the work should be done with lead-safe practices: containment, wet methods and proper cleanup. Ask any contractor how they handle it.

The usual answer

In a typical Milwaukee bungalow or Shorewood duplex, the answer is a mix: new windows where the old ones are rotted, drafty or failed, a repair where a window is sound, and storms on any originals that stay.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to repair or replace windows?

Repair is usually cheaper per window when the wood is sound. Replacement becomes the better value when rot is extensive or the window is a failed earlier replacement.

How do you fix an old window without replacing it?

For a sound window: free the sashes, replace the cords, fix loose or cracked glass, repair any soft wood and add weatherstripping.